UK Government to introduce independent Football Regulator

jsp

Well-Known Member
Top Poster Of Month
Joined
Feb 15, 2012
Messages
23,966

No timeframe for when it will come in but has to be a good thing the clubs clearly can't be trusted to look after themselves they act in their own interests not the interest of the game as a whole.

Clubs have been allowed to fall into the hands of owners who again do not always act in the interest of their fans and in some cases clubs have been run so poorly they no longer exist. Fans have no power to remove the owners and you get situations of constant on going protect against owners who've not looked after the club.
 

Cruella ne Ville

Moderator
Joined
Feb 21, 2021
Messages
1,395
Independent football regulator: Government White Paper outlines plans including powers around owners' tests and breakaway leagues

As with anything involving government or football these days, the proof will be in the pudding. Grandiose statements about what will and won't be allowed to happen need to be supported with action and enough legislative muscle to put them into practice. The obvious worry is that implementation will get challenged in the courts or certain brown envelopes will allow certain individuals to get around the laws and clubs and fans will still be left holding the bag.
 

jsp

Well-Known Member
Top Poster Of Month
Joined
Feb 15, 2012
Messages
23,966
Sounds like PR guff to me.

If you asked most fans what they care about most they'd probably say they want regulation on ticket prices, kick off times, policing on matchdays etc. Some of the laws around how football fans are treated compared to other members of the public need to be addressed.

The UK can't say they are a free market economy then on the other hand say the clubs at the top should subsidise the clubs at the bottom. Last time I checked Tesco didn't subsidise the local green grocers. If anything they go out of their way to put the competition out of business.

For me the regulation needs to be focused on clubs in the football league and non league. These are the clubs who are taking huge gambles with their future to try and get up to the premier league. Most of the clubs that have got themselves into a mess have been the clubs who've been reckless in chasing that dream like Derby.

The premier league will argue that the current financial fair play rules force clubs to be self sustaining in a way that they weren't 15 years ago.

I'd personally like to see all TV contracts signed by the premier league and EFL have a set % that goes towards local councils funding that helps cover the cost of maintenance and investment in public pitches so that the kids have half decent pitches to play on all year round.
 

Cruella ne Ville

Moderator
Joined
Feb 21, 2021
Messages
1,395
That's my initial read as well. If the government needs to step in, what is the purpose of the FA? Surely stewarding the game is their sole raison d'etre, but for some reason, they've shirked it at every opportunity.

They aren't a free market economy otherwise individual clubs would be allowed to sell their own TV rights packages, and the top clubs would be even further out of reach.

I don't think anyone would disagree with the notion that impartial regulation is necessary for the good of the game, and not individual clubs. In other words, exactly the opposite of the free market economy, which favours the survival of the fittest and best equipped.

The issues and driving forces are different down the pyramid, but if the Glazers get into bed with this Elliot group, we could very easily end up like Bury. Currently, parasitic ownership groups have been allowed to take over and strip billions from the game right under the watchful eye of the stewards, yet the potential fallout could be much much worse. Any regulatory body needs to stop owners like the Glazers from not only taking over in the first place, but imposing the levels of debts onto the club, and potentially borrowing from the equivalent of a loan shark.

Not sure more money down the pyramid is going to solve the problems. There will always be more money nearer the top, which will still drive owners of lower league clubs to chase the pot of gold at the end of whatever rainbow is the closest.
 

jsp

Well-Known Member
Top Poster Of Month
Joined
Feb 15, 2012
Messages
23,966
The premier league is a private entity with each club applying to be members. The premier league acts in the free market against other leagues on behalf of its members.

I dare say Utd is now in the state of being to big to fail.

It is hard to get a read on much of the Elliot stuff as I’m not exactly sure what they’re offering and to who. It seems like they’re open to backing any bidder than needs finance including the Glazers buying out the rest of the family.

Football clubs cannot be regulated in ways that don’t apply to other privately owned businesses. They aren’t key assets of national security
 

Login or Register

Forgot your password?
or Log in using
Don't have an account? Register now
Top