Andre Onana | Match Discussion Thread 2023/24

actually, gonna break it already.

Seen the goals, he should be saving all of those, first one, granted bad defending, but he should at least get a hand to that. Second one he should be saving no problem.

Third one, oh my god, what keeper dives with two hands like that, lead with one hand for extra reach. That's little league keeping, embarrassing

Even at his worst De Gea saves the second two. I'd even wager he'd save the first.

The way people were going on I was thinking he was unlucky.

Awful awful goal keeping. Awful defending too.

ETH is in big trouble, no excuses, his players.
 
actually, gonna break it already.

Seen the goals, he should be saving all of those, first one, granted bad defending, but he should at least get a hand to that. Second one he should be saving no problem.

Third one, oh my god, what keeper dives with two hands like that, lead with one hand for extra reach. That's little league keeping, embarrassing

Even at his worst De Gea saves the second two. I'd even wager he'd save the first.

The way people were going on I was thinking he was unlucky.

Awful awful goal keeping. Awful defending too.

ETH is in big trouble, no excuses, his players.

That helps, but it appears you were blaming him for all three goals before you even saw them, if not's not an agenda I don't know what is.
 
not at all, I've only spoken in general about the Brighton game and Onana once, and I clearly said I'd not seen it.

all my other comments are in general and don't mention the Brighton game

I haven't seen it yet, buts it's unlikely we are conceding this many goals and none of them onana should save. Every week fans absolve him, cos he passes nice. Keepers need to be keeping.
He's been a bad signing.
ETH is on sticky ground, especially if new owners come in. His signings have been poor.
 
If you think a keeper is saving either of them first two you must be joking.
 
nope, first one I said he should get a hand to, I think a top keeper saves it but 50/50. Second one a half decent keeper saves, his reactions seem slow. 3rd one is embarrassing

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
not at all, I've only spoken in general about the Brighton game and Onana once, and I clearly said I'd not seen it.

all my other comments are in general and don't mention the Brighton game

Fair enough but you do have form. One game last season you were on here destroying the team/numerous players on the strength of a radio commentary. At your vintage I hoped you would know better. Alan Green says Hi
 
nope, first one I said he should get a hand to, I think a top keeper saves it but 50/50. Second one a half decent keeper saves, his reactions seem slow. 3rd one is embarrassing

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.


There's not a keeper dead or alive that saves the first two, the third debatable, but in commentary it was described as a perfect shot, and there ain't many keepers that save those, the perfect shot should be a clue ....
 
Gotta say, radio Commentry on R5 is top class. Not heard old Alan Green for a while, dunno what happened to him
 
Gotta say, radio Commentry on R5 is top class. Not heard old Alan Green for a while, dunno what happened to him

Can't remember the last time the last time I listened to a radio commentary, probably 20+ years ago.

But on matches not involving United AG was different gravy, great to listen to, but if United were playing he could never hide his hatred of all things United which was sad.

Meant to check he was still alive before I posted the above. Memories totally gone. Was hanging on to the thought my short-term memory is still bang on :confused:
 
Awful for Bayern’s opener, his first proper goalkeeping mistake. Reminded me of goal conceded at West Ham last season.
 
Yeah our previous keeper had a few like that but with that big price tag on your back you really can’t be letting one like that in.

Up to that point he’d not put a foot wrong.
 
Recovered well after the gaff when you make a mistake the worst thing you can do is make another one.
 
Yeah played well after the mistake but that mistake killed our good work and ultimately lost us the game.
 
I thought he was good last 20 mins.

But yeah we lost belief after his mistake. We can put the goal down to him for sure. But the team needs to react better, be stronger mentally
 
We can say mentality all we want but some of it just comes down to ability.

There have to be serious questions about the individual ability of some of these players and also the lack of team shape both with and without the ball.

Nothing feels connected and it’s an on going problem.
 
They lack ability, speed of thought, control.

But they were doing ok, that goal affected them mentally way more than it should.
 
I thought he was good last 20 mins.

But yeah we lost belief after his mistake. We can put the goal down to him for sure. But the team needs to react better, be stronger mentally

You unpredictable b*stard, thought you'd be climbing into him for the mistake ;)
 
We can say mentality all we want but some of it just comes down to ability.

There have to be serious questions about the individual ability of some of these players and also the lack of team shape both with and without the ball.

Nothing feels connected and it’s an on going problem.

They lack ability, speed of thought, control.

But they were doing ok, that goal affected them mentally way more than it should.

Like two Fish Wives talking over the fence....

Meanwhile, back in the Andre Onana thread ....
 
Burnley 0-1 Man Utd

He needed a quiet game and that’s what he had, made some saves and took some crosses but his defence made sure Burnley only really had 1 good chance to score which luckily hit the post.
 
Did well.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
[/URL]
 
Good performance by onana, more like it.

Does love a dive with both arms out, weird
 
He has looked rubbish prior to yesterday, I actually thought, bar the error, he did ok vs BM
 
Oh Dear.

His mistake was bad but it should not cloud the absolute mess that was the reaction to both times we scored.
 
For who? Have you seen our back ups. More quality from the recruitment team. Why they let de Gea is beyond me. All keepers need pushing. How much did arsenal pay for Raya? Why didn't we go for him, we should go for ramsdale
 
For who? Have you seen our back ups. More quality from the recruitment team. Why they let de Gea is beyond me. All keepers need pushing. How much did arsenal pay for Raya? Why didn't we go for him, we should go for ramsdale

Yeah i'm surprised we let Spain's 9th choice keeper leave as well, what were we thinking :rolleyes:
 
I'm not surprised a keeper has had the confidence sucked out of him by joining a team that is giving opponents easy chances.

I do think they have to consider putting the Turkish lad in.
 

Login or Register

Forgot your password?
Don't have an account? Register now
or Log in using
Back
Top