A 4 from me not necessarily due to his performances which generally were very good he's a top class defender but the guy just can't stay fit he's played just over 1/2 of the league games this season, that is not good enough for a player on his sort of salary.
He needs to sort that out for next season we need to be able to call on him every week not in for 3 games out for 3 games which is kind of how it's been with him.