The Curious Case Of Nani


By David Gee (@DavidGee26)

Luis Carlos Almeida da Cunha; if only his list of match winning performances was as long as his name. However, despite undoubted talent Nani (as he is more commonly known) has produced a Manchester United career to date lamentably characterised and beset by one thing: inconsistency.

Having joined the club on the 1St July 2007 from Sporting Lisbon, the winger has gone on to make 230 appearances, scoring 41 goals. Winning the Premier League and Champions League double in his first season with the club and converting his crucial penalty in the shoot-out in Moscow, Nani matured as a player and went on to collect United’s Player of the Year award following a stellar campaign in 2010/11 as the Old Trafford outfit secured their record 19th title.

The Portuguese man was rewarded with a nomination for the 2011 Ballon d’Or, which only highlights the winger’s true quality when he finds his top form. Unfortunately, through niggling injuries or otherwise, Nani has failed to push on and maintain those high standards and has become a point of frustration amongst his teammates and fans alike in recent years.

The frustration, of course, largely emanates from the obvious abundance of talent at the winger’s disposal, and having penned a new five-year deal in September 2013 it is obvious that despite erratic performances many at the club still feel that United’s no.17 has plenty to offer.

Regrettably, Nani was restricted to just 13 appearances last season through injury and on the 20th August 2014 the Portuguese winger returned to Sporting Lisbon on a one-year loan deal as part of a deal to bring defender Marcos Rojo to Old Trafford.

The loan may well signal the end of Nani’s time at Manchester United but there is always a possibility that a move away and consistent playing time may rejuvenate the winger and help him to re-discover his best form. The potential and ability has always been plain to see, but far too often consistent application has been found wanting.

His signing originally fell firmly in line with the mantra that Manchester United don’t buy stars, they make them. But by extension, the lamentable reality is that Nani is indicative of what has become patently obvious as a much larger issue at Old Trafford that has certainly come to a head following Sir Alex Ferguson’s departure.

The Red Devils’ decline in form over the last 12 months has led to widespread inquests in search of explanations. Despite a promising pre-season Van Gaal’s start to life at the helm has certainly brought Moyes’ tenure into perspective. For all the criticism levied at the Scot, it is obvious that the problems run much deeper and Nani’s career at United is a pertinent example of the club’s failings and lack of cohesion in the transfer market over recent years which in no small part is contributing to the Old Trafford outfit’s woes.

That is not to label Nani as a flop, he has certainly had his moments and even if consistency was never found, for most the potential and ability is obvious enough to have warranted his acquisition. Buying players like Nani is not the problem, you have to take risks with potential because without the Nanis and the Bebes you don’t get the Ronaldos and the Januzajs, but the club’s management thereafter surely has to come into question.

Many of the club’s often maligned players, the likes of Nani, Young, Valencia and Anderson all earn big wages. The consequence of this is that it becomes very difficult to move them on should they become surplus to requirements. Many eyebrows were raised at the winger’s new five-year deal last September, and rightly so.

For a period of 5 years towards the end of Ferguson’s tenure, Manchester United had a lower net spend on transfers than Stoke City and Aston Villa. That is not to say that investment was not made and this article is certainly not going to embark upon a Glazer debate, but the problems now are becoming increasingly apparent.

The truth is that a club of Manchester United’s stature have criminally underinvested in recent years and the majority of investments made, particularly towards the end of Ferguson’s tenure, have proven to have been poor ones. The Scot’s sheer brilliance papered over the cracks but the flaws in the Red Devils’ squad and planning have been brutally exposed over the last 12 months and, to a certain extent, Nani is a case-in-point.

Whilst the winger’s new deal may safeguard the receipt of a transfer fee, the scale of the wages offered make it difficult for interested clubs to produce a viable deal. The consequence is that during Nani’s one-year loan spell his wages will be paid in full by United.

There does not appear to have been much foresight at the club for sometime regarding incomings and outgoings. Even the suitability of the likes of Mata and Kagawa to United’s style of play have to come into question despite their obvious talent.

Incredibly, since Ronaldo’s departure the club’s three most valuable sales have been Zoran Tosic (£8.4m), Ben Foster (£6.2m) and Alex Buttner (£4.8m), whilst stellar names such as Vidic, Ferdinand, Evra and Berbatov have all been allowed to leave either on a free transfer or for nominal fees.

The previous spending and obvious quality of the present day Chelsea and Manchester City sides have necessitated huge investment in United’s squad and in this sense it is refreshing that this summer the club appear to have recognised this. Premiums and inflated prices will have to be paid but it is surely a lesser evil than continuing with a squad which has regrettably been exposed as woefully short.

Reports suggest that the likes of Kagawa, Hernandez, Cleverley, Lindegaard, Fellaini and Anderson may all follow Nani out of the Old Trafford exit door. The much mooted squad overhaul appears to be kicking into gear under Louis van Gaal of which Nani has fallen victim and the last few days of the transfer window should prove interesting viewing.

It is refreshing that the Dutchman possesses a clear and unwavering philosophy which should hopefully be reflected in any further acquisitions.

As for the curious case of Nani, talent, trickery and potential; oh what might have been

What are your thoughts? Share in the comments section below CLICK HERE.

Like Stretford End Arising on Facebook CLICK HERE.
Register with SEA’s forum CLICK HERE.

Subscribe via Email

Subscribe to our free email newsletter and never miss a post!

I agree to have my personal information transfered to MailChimp ( more information )

I will never give away, trade or sell your email address. You can unsubscribe at any time.


  1. Very good thoughtful article. That’s what’s so frustrating about Nani: loads of talent, but increasingly hopeless application. The stats about transfer fees received since Ronaldo sale are truly astonishing.

  2. Very good article and fair comment regarding Nani, I thought. I have seen some great moments in a Red Shirt from Nani. On his day, he could be brilliant. The trouble was, though, that those days were simply not frequent enough! Sadly, all too often, he was so frustrating!

    Also hit the nail on the head re the transfers in the past few seasons. The most recent titles, 19th and 20th, wonderful though they were, served to paper over the cracks. That paper was torn down last season under Moyes and now LvG has started what is essentially a repair job. I feel he knows what he’s doing and his repairs should be supported.

    Do hope we can get more defenders though. Woefully short at the back and Evans had an absolute mare against MK Dons. I worry when he plays, he does seem a liability.

  3. Nani is a great player any day. If he could be given six consecutive games I still have confidence in him. I think the biggest challenge he faces is basically that, when he plays after he recovers from an injury, if his performance isn’t up to what the fans expect, they start saying all manner of things. He was Portugal’s best player at the WC and, when he came on against Sunderland, he was quite impressive. Give him a chance!

  4. Any time I come across an article on Nani, I am usually unhappy about the criticism. Because it is very easy criticize and analyze. We forget the human side of these players which we all share in common. After Rooney’s scandal in 2010-2011 he has never recovered to this previous goal scoring form. In fact he when almost a year without scoring but was never criticized this much. He was allowed to play almost every match(despite the fact that he said he wanted to leave) until he recovered his confidence. Same with Van persie(when he went three months without scoring in Fergusons last season in charge).
    Was Nani given a similar chance? NO! I sometimes wonder what is special about Valencia who is considered a better alternative. This is someone who was given the famous no 7 shirt and he rejected it because for the terrible form that followed that season. He lacks creativity and is very predictable in his movements. In fact the only thing is see special about him is is amazing work rate and strength. The story is the same for Wayne Rooney. They all have good work rate but fail to assist and score respectively which is their primary duty. Yet this two have not been placed in the same level of criticism

    All players have crisis period in their career and we have to support them through that period. As they say, FORM IS TEMPORARY BUT CLASS IS PERMANENT. They don’t give national captain bands to average players. Let us not be bias and inhumane in our comments as we place unrealistic expectations on people, expectations which we don’t want others to place on us.
    Nani may never be like Ronaldo but let us support him to be the best he can be.

  5. You cannot compare Nani to Wazza or RvP!

    Wayne and Robin, and most other players, are footballers who perform extremely well most of the time and have the occasional off day. Nani, on the other hand, only performed every now and again and ran around like a headless chicken the rest of the time!

    Also, RvP did NOT go three months without scoring! The only month in the 2012-13 season in which he didn’t score was March, as he scored on 10th February vs Everton and then 14th April vs Stoke, so Gideon should get his facts right! Even when he wasn’t scoring, though, he was still setting up goals for his team mates, providing assists for others and generally doing a damn sight more than Nani usually did!

    Having finally got some quality players this summer, we have been able to offload a few of our serial under-performers and Nani was definitely one of those!

  6. *smiles*
    Players have different Classes in my opinion. We have the messi, suarez,ronaldo top class, very good players(rvp, falcao)good players(Nani, marcelo, thiago etc) and then the average players(valencia, young, mikel etc)

    This is just my opinion though. So may disagree.But google up what our Almighty ferguson had to say about Nani. I am sure you will respect his opinion.

    As for Rooney, he does nothing out of the ordinary for me. 10+ in the premier league as a striker without a golden boot says it all. so many foreigners have come to England within this period had a golden boot. As a striker, you are expected to score first and then assist. Bale didnt become the most expensive player because of assists.

    Nani on the other hand has lost all his confidence but we know he has the skill. he almost came back but messed up at the champions league match real madrid. That what is lowest point for me.

    my conclusion.
    We can remember the season when manchester united almost went unbeaten. Nani was tagged as a world class player by the EPL commentators then. i remember is goal against wolverhampton on the day our unbeaten record was broken, the commentator said something like “this guy is simply unstoppable”. Also check his champions league average performances on whoscored for seasons between 2010 to 2012. he had very average ratings has compared to other manchester players.

    So i ask, Do we support our players when the reward us with good performance and “lash” them when they are struggling to get back to their form?

    As for me, I will support everybody through their bad and good times. As the sum of it all makes up their careers. Thank you

Leave A Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.