Reserves Match Review: Manchester City v Manchester United


Manchester United reserves faced local rivals Manchester City (Elite Development Squad) in the Manchester Senior Cup at Ewen Field on Tuesday evening. Ole Gunnar Solskjaer was allowed the luxury of selecting several established first team regulars including: Gary Neville; Wes Brown, Michael Carrick and a welcome return to action for Anderson after a six month layoff due to injury.

United created the first real opportunity in the 9th minute. Chris Smalling punted a searching pass for Rafael (playing left back); the young Brazilian controlled the ball superbly and slid a pass to Carrick. Carrick whipped a cross over with the ball finding its way to the impressive Magnus Eikrem – he delivered a precise cross finding the head of Cleverley, who smacked the ball against the crossbar.

Two minutes later City opened the scoring via Alex Nimely. The build was impressive: Abdisalam Ibrahim, Scott Kay and Nimely were all involved in short intricate passing. Ibrahim attempted to slide a through ball (I believe) to Chris Chantler, good defending from Chris Smalling blocked the pass, but the rebound fell to Ibrahim who slid a short pass to Nimely, he scored with an effort from the edge of penalty area leaving Ben Amos little chance.

After taking the lead City defended from their own half allowing United to enjoy plenty of possession without any real penetration as City were well organised and difficult to breakdown. The pattern of the match remained the same until the 37th minute when Neville fired in a low cross gathered by Federico Macheda. The young Italian tried to spin Reece Wabara, but the City defender blocked his efforts and the ball rebounded to Cleverley. Cleverley attempted a curling shot, but the effort lacked the bend to find the corner of the net. A minute later Macheda had his man, as he foxed Wabara with an excellent turn and powered home a shot past City’s Colombian goalkeeper David González. Eikrem providing his first assist of the game.

After the equaliser United upped the tempo and looked a greater threat as City became pinned in their own half. Darron Gibson had a rasping shot bravely blocked by City captain Ben Mee and good goalkeeping prevented Cleverley from latching on to a through ball. The first half ended with United on top.

As the second half started United continued to push City back towards their own penalty area. After sixty minutes Anderson was replaced by Will Keane. Anderson’s performance was okay considering he hasn’t played since February. He was decent in possession – some nice flicks and passing. He also wasn’t afraid got stuck in. He perhaps was carrying a little additional weight in my opinion, which is to be expected. He will no doubt lose the extra padding once he’s in the full swing of training. Joe Dudgeon also replaced Rafael.

In Nimely, City still offered an attacking threat. He pounced on a poor back pass from Brown and rounded Amos to only have his shot blocked by the excellent Smalling. Another incident he turned Neville, which brought a smart low save from Amos.

After a poor first half Gibson’s influence on the game began to grow. During the 72nd minute he started the move which lead to Macheda grabbing his second goal and a deserved lead for United. From the left wing position Gibson crossed low into the penalty and via a Keane touch the ball arrived to Eikrem. The young Norwegian fainted a pass to the over lapping Neville and passed inside to Macheda, who found the back of the net with a sweetly hit shot. A minute later Oliver Gill replaced Carrick.

Three minutes after taking the lead United virtually sealed the victory by adding a third goal. On the right hand side the pantomimed booed Neville found Cleverley on the edge of City’s penalty area, he in turn found Keane with a short sharp pass. Similar to Macheda, Keane tried to spin his defender and shoot, but Mee blocked his attempt. The ball fell into the path of Cleverley who finished coolly to finally add his name to the score sheet. City pushed forward during the final ten minutes but United were relatively comfortable to run out 3-1 winners.

City played extremely well considering the strength of the United team selected, especially for the first thirty minutes or so. Smalling and Eikrem were stand out players for United. Smalling really impressed with a commanding performance, which included good distribution, several instances of good blocking and strength when required. His best performance in a United shirt and encouraging signs.

United’s Starting XI: Ben Amos, Gary Neville, Rafael, Wes Brown, Chris Smalling, Michael Carrick, Darron Gibson, Anderson, Tom Cleverley, Federico Macheda, Magnus Eikrem.
Register with Stretford End Arising forum

Subscribe via Email

Subscribe to our free email newsletter and never miss a post!

I agree to have my personal information transfered to MailChimp ( more information )

I will never give away, trade or sell your email address. You can unsubscribe at any time.


  1. Erik - City Fan in the States on

    come on…. Even as a City fan I know Man United have a bevie of young talent on hand… why trot out all your first team bench players in a competition such as this? i think city is using the sesible approach and still working to give young developing players a chance to shine in the reserves as they learn to ply their trade. Sure, we could have fielded a solid squad with the likes of Jo, Adebayor, Boyata, Given, Vieira, Silva, SWP amongst others…. Were all the Man U senior players featured because they were coming off injury (Neville) or what? Weird. You would think SAF would use the Cup Games and some of his ‘easier” CL games to give his bench players a run out…. Anyway. Witht eh first round of results fromt he league, it looks to be a great season ahead of both sets of fans and the derby games will be crackers for sure…

    • Stretford End Arising on

      Hello Erik, welcome.

      Reckon the World Cup is the reason why United selected a strong team. Players are lacking in match fitness and minutes on the pitch.Think United’s starting line-up is likely to be a one off. The main aim to give the likes of Carrick, Rafael, Brown game time as they havent featured for first team. Neville and Anderson are making comebacks from injury for their reason in playing.

      Having said that: Amos; Smalling, Rafael, Gibson, Cleverley; Eikrem, Anderson and Macheda are young. 8 of the 11 are 22 or younger.

      Can’t wait for the Derby’s. What are your expectations for City this season, Erik?

  2. Utd kids run the show, an easy win over the bitters. on

    Enjoyable game, i actually felt gibbo had a good run out displaying many neat touches, good dribbles and some exqusite passes. Ando looked fit and ready to go, nice see the brazilian bull back. Cleverley continues to make me look a football genius, the kid is one hell of a talent and i stand by my statement that he be the next big thing, Kiko looked sharp and deadly. I find it funny how folks fail mention citey gk gonzalez is 28, yet mentions carrick & co- our main men was there strictly for match-fitness.

    • Stretford End Arising on

      Felt Gibson struggled during first half – his passing was sloppy at times I thought. He improved during the second though.

      Was impressed with Cleverley once again. Really hope he is given an opportunity. Perhaps when we’re playing twice a week he is more likely to feature.

      Macheda’s finishing was high class. Will he be given an opportunity?

  3. Utd kids run the show, an easy win over the bitters. on

    Utd kids last night- Amos (20), Rafael (20), Gibson (22), Eikrem (20), Macheda (19), Cleverley (21), W.Keane (17), Gill (19) Dudgeon (19) then there’s the ‘brazilian bull’ Anderson (22)….all played last night, all did well especially Cleverley who ran the show and was the star on display, he be the next big thing- watch the lad go, the future talisman of the Utd midfield…Keane, Rafa, Eikrem has big futures ahead of them here along with Gibbo, Kiko, but none more thou then Cleverley who be a superstar.

Leave A Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.