Player Ratings: Scunthorpe United vs. Manchester United


Starting XI:

Kuszczak – 7: Plenty of work to enjoy – dealt with numerous shots from Scunthorpe – including a couple of good saves. Future Manchester United No.1? I have doubts – he is a good shot stopper, but questions surround his ability to claim crosses and poor distribution.

Brown – 6: Did okay – much better in the final 10-15 minutes. Not back to his best yet – another who requires further game time.

Smalling – 8: Excellent performance – an assist, his first goal and comfortable in defence – made several blocks. Impressed since his arrival – he looks a bargain at £10m.

Rio Ferdinand – 6.5: Still finding his way – desperate for game time. Was relieved and pleased he was able to continue after landing awkwardly on his back.

Rafael – 6.5: First start of the season, disappointingly at left back. Not sure what else to discuss about his performance – got stuck in?

Anderson – 7: Quiet-ish first half, but improved as the game wore on, especially his passing – he has the ability to provide the creative spark when Scholes is rested. Delighted he completed 90 minutes, which is a rare occurrence – a positive.

Gibson – 7: If not for the goal he would have received a score of 6. Brilliant goal, but his passing disappointed – sloppy at times.

Park – 7.5: Poor to begin, but improved vastly during the latter stages of first half and maintained this form until he was replaced in the second half. A goal plus heavily involved for Smalling & Owen’s second goal.

Hernandez – 5.5: Why on the right wing? Man United’s new signing is not a right winger – couple of decent crosses but little else of real note. His ability is being wasted in this role. Hope the intention is not to convert him into a right winger. Perhaps roughed up?

Owen – 7.5: Another that had a quiet first half, but excellent during the second – dropped deeper therefore more involved. Two typical Owen goals – who doubted he would miss the one v one opportunity to grab his first goal? Not me. He will score goals – how many opportunities will he receive though..?

Macheda – 6.5: Started wide on the left – extremely quiet. Switched into a central role – more involved and looked hungry for a goal – missed one or two chances. Good assist for Owen’s first goal. Will enjoy better nights.

Obertan – 5: Tried in attack and prepared to track back in defence. Surprised he did not start ahead of Hernandez – he would have benefited from a full 90 minutes, considering the injury to Valencia.

Bebe – 5: Limited time to make a real impression. He looks strong, confident, plenty of pace and direct running.

If you wish to discuss this issue further with myself or other members of the Stretford End Arising community, you can do so in the forum

Subscribe via Email

Subscribe to our free email newsletter and never miss a post!

I agree to have my personal information transfered to MailChimp ( more information )

I will never give away, trade or sell your email address. You can unsubscribe at any time.

1 Comment

  1. smalling 10 vision class ball control class speed second to no. aslo man united are every colse to sign david dae gael. i would have out fergie up for the nite in velencia if i knew he was coming and eric steele to.

Leave A Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.