Player Ratings: Sunderland v Manchester United


Sunderland 0-0 Manchester United

Starting XI

Van der Sar – 7: Made a cracking one v one save plus a couple more decent saves, but otherwise little else to do.

Rafael – 7.5: Second consecutive impressive game for the young Brazilian. Harassed and closed down opponents and offered more going forward compared to his performance against Valencia. Finally I can stop discussing the right back spot in my match preview articles, surely..?

Ferdinand -7.5: I’ve erred on the side of caution where Rio has been concerned – I was wrong to do so. Has he really been absent for 5 months? He has walked back into the team seamlessly. Guess the old saying “class is permanent” rings true when referring to Rio.

Vidic – 7.5: Strong committed performance from the big Serbian. With his surges down the left is he the solution to the left wing dilemma? “Vidic Will Tear You Apart Again” doesn’t have quite the same ring to it…

O’Shea – 6: A better defensive performance compared to recent weeks from the Irishman, but less effective going forward. Although Evra is still searching for peek form we missed his attacking thrust down the left wing.

Scholes – 5.5: Unable to influence proceedings.

Fletcher – 5.5: Pretty much the same as Scholes – extremely quiet game. The Darren Fletcher of last season is badly needed in away fixtures – midfield is simply being overrun – much of the first half was played inside United’s half.

Anderson – 5.5: He was the best of a dire midfield – used his strength/power to make one or two surging runs – perhaps l. Lacked movement in making himself available, but still lacking match fitness/sharpness therefore deserves leeway.

Nani – 5.5: Extremely poor first half – sloppy passing and greedy on one occasion when Owen and Anderson were relatively free inside the penalty area. He slightly improved during the second half, but overall a disappointing performance.

Macheda – 5: Both he and Owen barely touched during their time on field – not necessarily their fault with midfield offering little service.

Owen – 5: See Macheda.


Berbatov – 6: Man United improved once the Bulgarian replaced Owen. He came to life during the final 10-15 minutes and came the closest to scoring.

Hernandez – 6: Added a spark in attack plus linked well with Berbatov.

Bebe: Little time to make an impression or warrant a score.

Man of the Match: Rafael or Vidic

If you wish to discuss this issue further with myself or other members of the Stretford End Arising community, you can do so in the Stretford End Arising Forum

Subscribe via Email

Subscribe to our free email newsletter and never miss a post!

I agree to have my personal information transfered to MailChimp ( more information )

I will never give away, trade or sell your email address. You can unsubscribe at any time.


  1. Fletcher 4-non existent, poor the entire season so far

    Scholesy 5-was off but can’t be expected 2 do it all evryX

    Anderson 5.5-needs 2 get some confidence NOW b/ was best in midfield especially after he got a lil angry…hahaha

    Nani 5.5-had an arrogant game, sloppy game but showed more passion then rest of midfield

    OShea 6-Never play @ LB again…NEVER

    Macheda 4-overrated

    Owen 4-awesome sub until midfield gets better then perhaps he can start…hahaha

    Raphael, Vidic, Rio & VDS deserve 8

    Agree w/ rest b/ must say I was pi55ed Chicarito didn’t start. Then Bebe introduction so late was ridiculous. I’m tired of playing draws. We WON”T win the PL w/ draws. But, I guess CL is SAF main concern, right?

  2. i cant beilve the at monment of stick fergie is getting on manchester eveing news forunm is it city fans talking a joke our what

  3. ya fergie out and all that but i think it city fans talking a jioke and saying there man united fans but the realy city fans. fergie will turn it around we alwayd start of bad this time of year fergie is god

Leave A Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.