Match Preview: Liverpool vs. Manchester United


By Sleepy

Sir Alex Ferguson will be taking charge of his 950th top-flight game this weekend as Manchester United seek to get back on track for that ever elusive 19th league title push at Anfield on Sunday. Motivation will be high after the perceived injustice of the midweek loss to Chelsea, combined with the fact that this is the game most Man United players (and fans) look for when the fixtures are released at the season’s start.


Liverpool vs. Manchester United Formations

Probable United Starting Lineup (3-5-2 v 4-4-1-1)

Credit: This11

United will be without their strongest centre half partnership with Ferdinand missing due to injury and Vidic suspended after committing a costly foul on Ramires midweek. Brown should earn a recall alongside Smalling then after a decent goal-scoring outing versus Crawley of late. The perennially injured Brown is a seasoned campaigner and will have no problem coming into such a high profile fixture. The pair will likely be flanked by Evra and O’Shea – Evra picked up a knock at Stamford Bridge but should come through for this pivotal game. O’Shea should keep his place ahead of Rafael, largely down to the fact he is enjoying a rich vein of form; as well as being strong in the tackle he has worked hard on his offensive play, making himself available on the overlap in attack with aplomb in recent matches.

In midfield, Fergie will have to decide whether to deploy five across the middle to match the Liverpool system of 3-5-2 under Kenny Dalglish, or whether to combat this using a similar 4-4-2 to the one deployed versus Chelsea.  I think the latter is likely given that Liverpool’s system relies on the fullbacks to provide width and with three centre halves quite static at the back; Playing a lone striker to crowd the midfield would mean a 3 v 1 situation for Liverpool in that area of the field, and so is distinctly different to the 4-2-3-1 system in that sense. Scholes also looked tired v Chelsea, and without Anderson, United’s best strategy could be to place the combative Fletcher (who was excellent on the right at Chelsea) alongside Carrick in the middle with Giggs and Nani providing width.

As an aside, both Carrick and Fletcher were awarded new bumper contracts this week and are essential to the continued success of the club going forward.  After suffering a season to forget last term, Carrick in particular has become a scapegoat for fan frustration; yet a return to form this year is surely a reminder to his critics that on form, he is superior to his league counterparts in Barry, Mikel, Lucas, Huddlestone – and even the fantastic upcoming talent of Jack Wilshere at the present time.

Giggs will seek to get on the ball in more central positions as we have seen quite often this season (see chalkboard); The Welshman, who will break Sir Bobby Charlton’s league appearance record if he plays, is an astute reader of the game, and as versus City recently, his decision making will be key – Giggs likes to stay central when in defensive positions and without the ball and stay wide and work in tandem with Evra in attacking scenarios on the counter. Getting in behind weak-link Johnson could prove fruitful.

Giggs vs. Sunderland Passes Heatmap

Giggs heatmap v Sunderland: Central (click to enlarge)

Credit: Guardian Chalkboards

Manchester United Passes vs Manchester City

United passes v Man City: Staying wide (click to enlarge)

Credit: Guardian Chalkboards

Berbatov should start the game having been rested in the last two. He will be disappointed in having to sit out the trip down south, but Fergie was justified in starting the goal scoring Mexican, who was tasked with pulling Terry out of position at every opportunity. Hernandez deserved the recognition of a ‘big game’ after a fantastic start to his United career, having largely impacted from the bench. If Berbatov starts, he will need to remain high up the field and leave the creative duties to Rooney, ensuring that Carragher, Skrtl and Agger (or Kyrgiakos) are occupied. Nani will work closely with Rooney who will search for the ball from deep and who looked lively in the first 60 minutes against Chelsea, scoring his first goal from outside the area in the league since Newcastle away in 2008 – he was also a threat coming in from the left, and very nearly finished the game at 1-0.  When Rooney pulls into wide positions, Nani could have success in coming into central positions, using Berbatov’s clever movement to create openings, which he has exploited in deadly fashion this season.

Liverpool have Kelly out injured and worries over Agger and Aurelio, but are otherwise at full strength.  Dalglish may be tempted to revert to a 4-5-1 with Maxi coming in on the left, but it is not overly likely given the relative success the team has had with the new system. The key will be controlling the central areas and using the width provided by the wing-backs – and whilst Gerrard and Meireles have been earning the plaudits this term for their attacking qualities however, Lucas has been quietly superb, adding strength on the ball and the ability to snuffle out the danger in much the same way Mascherano did for the team, to his ability to play the strategic pass. The chalkboard below shows how he attempted 13 tackles in the 1-0 win at Chelsea recently, dismantling the attacks by harrying the midfield and wide players. (Carrick too completed 5 interceptions in the Chelsea fixture, highlighting his importance defensively).

Lucas Tackles & Carrick Interceptions

Lucas and Carrick importance (click to enlarge)

Credit: Guardian Chalkboards

Meireles will alternate with Gerrard, pushing on and supporting Suarez and Kuyt in attacking situations; Kuyt may also adopt a right-side position at times and interchange with the aforementioned midfielders. Suarez’s movement is fantastic, and his particular forte is being able to drift in from left to centre, meaning that O’Shea will have to be alert to the threat, and work in tandem with Brown and Smalling to avert danger.

In Summary

Fergie may be tempted to stick to a 4-4-1-1 formation meaning that the wide areas in the final third can be exploited on the counter attack if Johnson and Auerlio get caught up the field. Lucas and Gerrard will want to control the ball better in the middle than in the cup fixture at Old Trafford as United dominated that area even before Gerrard was sent off. Suarez has replaced Torres in the side since then, and is quickly becoming a crowd favourite with some clever movement and the ability to poach for a goal in the opposition penalty area. Passions will be high, but the focus of the team should solely be on the attainment of 3 league points and moving that little bit closer to the title Sir Alex craves.

Referee: Phil Dowd. A strong referee for a tough fixture. Experienced, and arguably the league’s most on-form referee at present. Will seek to control the game early, and is not averse to using either card.

Prediction: United are 6/4 to win the game. Back Rooney first scorer and 0-2 at 50/1 or choose Nani at 75/1.
Register with Stretford End Arising forum.

Subscribe via Email

Subscribe to our free email newsletter and never miss a post!

I agree to have my personal information transfered to MailChimp ( more information )

I will never give away, trade or sell your email address. You can unsubscribe at any time.


  1. Not that biased an article for a manc as for new contracts and Giggs ,first of all if Fergie had money i dont think Carrick would have got one , and i know giggs wouldn,t have got one ,one thing Fergie has never had is sentiment to players , lack of funds now mean he has to , Johnson will piss all over giggs for pace these days , now i am not comparing the two as in his pomp giggs would have bollocked him but his pace has gone and as for his shooting abilities as a fellow welshman will have to say abysmal his shots have always either a burst the net or more often or not hit the corner flag down, and i notice you only have eleven on the field tomorrow so we should start equal.

  2. Thanks for comment Anon.

    Think Johnson is your weakest link, defensively lapse at times.

    Am I take it you thought the tackle on Berbatov wasnt worthy of a penalty? As a referee I can say that this would be given 90% of the time – just as incidentally, the Smalling on Zhirkov would be too.

    May I also remind you of Mr Cann’s flag-waving exploits in the reverse fixture. The Torres dive (not bounce) was in full flow that day, and elicited a penalty which is perhaps only given 40% of the time.

  3. Interesting views Nik, I can’t argue with the line up as much as I am tempted to find a way to squeeze Hernandez in I feel his impact could be best off the bench. Rooney had his best game for a while on Tuesday so hopefully he can build on that and ask questions of the Liverpool back three – I think the key will be movement. If Rooney sits deep and central then I would imagine Lucas would happily take on the role of minder. As you point out by switching with Nani and Giggs we would be less predictable and make it more difficult to frustrate us. Although I completely understand your logic on the 3v1 issue I would still favour more of a 4-2-3-1 formation with Giggs and Nani playing relatively high to exploit space behind Johnson and Aurelio. I am confident enough in Evra to deal with Johnson and likewise O’Shea with Aurelio. One possible tactical battle will be the movement of Kuyt and Suarez who are comfortable pulling into wide areas. It is important Brown and Smalling don’t get dragged out of position.

    Incidentally with all due respect to the previous commenter I very much doubt Ryan Giggs will be losing sleep over Glen Johnson tonight!

  4. Sudheesh Marar on

    first of all congrats on getting the formation correct in the game against chelsea,although we didnot get the result we wanted in the end.I agree with your point of view that if Liverpool play with 3 men at back,playin a lone striker wudn be a good idea at all,I would like to see the same formation like the one we saw against chelsea,with carrick and flethcher in the middle,but just in case if fergie start with a 4-5-1, i wud like to know your opinion about playing giggs in the middle as an advanced playermaker,with carrick n fletcher partnering him in midfield,by this way i think sir alex can utilize the creativity of giggs,i think its a good choice,especially since giggs will be fresher havin played only a few min in the game against chelsea and scholsey really looked tired as the game progressed,Would like to hear your thoughts on this possibility, my intial feeling is a 1-2 win for us,with berba weavin some magic if he gets the start, cheers 🙂

  5. Although Nik might feel differently I am sceptical of Giggs as an advanced playmaker. For all his attributes I feel he has been quite wasteful in this role in the past, often trying too hard to force a pass which isn’t there meaning we lose possession in a dangerous position. If he carries on his improved form from Tuesday I would be happier with Rooney in this role although I wouldn’t be adverse to seeing Nani in this position as a Central winger. Perhaps experiments should be left for more minor fixtures, I would expect a 4-4-2 tomorrow hopefully with the same level of pressing and intensity we witnessed for half an hour on Tuesday which I’m confident would be enough to put Liverpool to bed.

  6. Question for you all do you think if fergie had the money of say 8to 9 years ago do you feel these same players would be getting new contracts ie Giggs. taking age into account.

  7. Yes. Giggs is instrumental. Better than most £30million signings Man City have made too.

    And I’m a Liverpool fan!

  8. Hi Sudheesh/Tom

    I can see the point that both of you try to make; Giggs has had some relative success in the role just beyond Carrick and Fletcher, a particular game versus Chelsea in recent seasons comes to mind. Though I am with Tom in that he can be very wasteful when in a very advanced position, I can sometimes understand his deployment there – in much the same way I can do with Park – if the game demands some nuance on the ball; i.e. not exactly tasked with providing the creative spark behind the forward line, but by keeping the ball, and using it intelligently – whether that be direct running at the opposition on simples passes to the wide areas.


    Rooney is able to drop deep and provide the creativity, but I often feel that he lacks the maturity and finesse to become a true trequartista, which is slightly different to his current false 9. What all this means of course is that a) we probably need to buy a Pastore/Ninis type player and b) if we dont, why not try Nani in there, working from the centre, and drifting to both the left and right wing areas…… 🙂

  9. As i said you lot keep drooling over Giggs all you want, all good things come to an end and his sell by date is up , Tom i see that confidence took a huge dent today counting chickens and all that.

Leave A Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.