Newcastle Utd vs Manchester Utd Player ratings

Red Warrior

Well-Known Member
May 8, 2017
DDG - 7 great one handed save, not too much else to do

AWB - 7 looked quite lively and got a great goal
Maguire - 8 great to see him play better and get a goal
Lindelof - 6 did what he needed to
Shaw - 6 looks like he is pushing forward a bit more but he's left that move way too late, he's got a problem on his hands if Telles hits the ground running

Fred - 6 gives the ball away still too much
McT - 6 did an ok job

James- 6 Better from him but still not good enough, no end product and his decision making remains an issue. He is Anreas Perriera reincarnate.
Bruno - 8 He did in and did well even with a penalty miss. Fantastic goal to end a brilliant team move
Mata - 8 Best game from him for a long time, had space to operate in which suited him

Rashford - 8 Lively, give it all performance and deserved a goal at the end.

Subs: Matic, Pogba and VDB - all 8 when the quality came on the game changed and we switched it up and made it look easy.


Well-Known Member
Feb 15, 2012
De Gea 8 no mistakes and made some good saves.

AWB 7 solid and got his goal
Maguire 7 same as above
Lindelof 7 Solid
Shaw 7 Solid

McTominay 7
Fred 7

James 6 on the fringes a bit but much improved from recent months.
Bruno 8 was there in the key moments as he always is probably fuming about missing a penalty but made up for it later on
Mata 9 Given time and space he had their pants down really found little pockets of space which caused them problems and linked really well with Bruno.

Rashford 8 best performance since he suffered that injury last year looked bang up for it lets hope he can build on this.

Login or Register

Forgot your password?
or Log in using
Don't have an account? Register now