- Joined
- Feb 15, 2012
- Messages
- 28,181
Inspired by the recent Official Man Utd podcast where they did an interview with Nani thought I'd make him the subject of my first one of these.
You need to give him an overall mark out of 10 based only on his time at Man Utd.
So on this scale
Giggs is a 10.
Tiabi is a 1. ( I don't care if his first game was a solid performance at Anfield after that he was dreadful).
Nani for me was one of those guys who on his day was unstoppable and capable of the truly bonkers but on an off day he made everyone around him.
He never hid away always wanted the ball and always took risks in his play.
Scored some crucial goals and some amazing goals always seemed to be a guy for the big occasion as well.
I do wonder what would have happened to him if Carragher hadn't hobbled him at Anfield in 2010-11 he was flying that season really stepped up a level but he got injured and just couldn't get back in the team as Valencia hit some form. Think that season sort of summed him up a good player but not quite a great one.
Overall I'd have him as a 7/10 player
For those who enjoy podcasts the official club one is well worth a listen they get a mixture of current and ex players and you get a bit of their personality come through more than you get with MUTV interviews.
You need to give him an overall mark out of 10 based only on his time at Man Utd.
So on this scale
Giggs is a 10.
Tiabi is a 1. ( I don't care if his first game was a solid performance at Anfield after that he was dreadful).
Nani for me was one of those guys who on his day was unstoppable and capable of the truly bonkers but on an off day he made everyone around him.
He never hid away always wanted the ball and always took risks in his play.
Scored some crucial goals and some amazing goals always seemed to be a guy for the big occasion as well.
I do wonder what would have happened to him if Carragher hadn't hobbled him at Anfield in 2010-11 he was flying that season really stepped up a level but he got injured and just couldn't get back in the team as Valencia hit some form. Think that season sort of summed him up a good player but not quite a great one.
Overall I'd have him as a 7/10 player
For those who enjoy podcasts the official club one is well worth a listen they get a mixture of current and ex players and you get a bit of their personality come through more than you get with MUTV interviews.