By Nathan Lewis
Last weekend’s defeat in the Manchester derby has given renewed impetus to the doubting Thomas’ both inside and outside United’s support. Concern over defensive frailties persist with Louis van Gaal forced to field a central pairing of Michael Carrick and Paddy McNair for a large portion of the second half at Eastlands, and an injury crisis of a gargantuan proportion continuing to decimate the back line.
Still, although the Reds have now gone five games without a win on the road, those who are able to compare the football being played now to that of last season under David Moyes, will tell you of a marked improvement.
It baffled me following Sunday’s game to hear some fans questioning if we were playing any better than at this point last year. The wider media have exacerbated this feeling by pointing to statistics, our worst start since ’86, fewer points on the board at this stage than under Moyes. I feel that I speak for most of those who have watched every game this season when I say that these stats tell us nothing about Manchester United under Louis van Gaal. Save for the first three games of the season the football has been unquestionably better than the dour, toothless and tactically naïve performances under Moyes.
Our past two fixtures, against the best team in the league and the reigning champions, have shown that we are closer to them then some might have you believe. We were utterly annihilated at the Etihad last year and our home match with Mourinho’s Chelsea threw up a tedious 0-0 draw. Compare that with this year’s game at Old Trafford in which we saw that famous never-say-die attitude – coupled with a sweat soaked display – return to United’s game. Similarly at Eastlands, Van Gaal’s men more than matched City until Smalling’s dismissal on 39 minutes and looked by far the more likely to score as the match drew to a close. This being in spite of the fact we were a man down and playing with a back four that would have reduced most Reds to a quivering wreck had we known that we would end the game with such a defence before hand.
It would appear from this that United’s lowly league position of 9th would have more to do with our porous defence than any perceived continuation of the troubles from last season’s nightmarish campaign. Unfortunately, the aforementioned injury crisis cannot be attributed sole proportion of the blame for these lapses, indeed it only serves to gloss over the fact that question marks remain over the quality of all of our current centre-halves. Phil Jones is for me the only man we have whose performances suggest he can play a big part in the future of the club. All-to-frequent injuries remain his only stumbling block, but for Jonny Evans, Chris Smalling and, to a lesser extent, Marcos Rojo, all have yet to show they have the desired quality to live up to the standards set by club stalwarts in their position such as Steve Bruce, Jaap Stam and Nemanja Vidic. This of course is a big concern, and unlikely to be solved until the summer. United will be no doubt looking to buy in January but as we all know, it’s not the easiest time to recruit.
Questions of quality aside, what United need more than ever is stability and a settled back four in order to stand any chance of turning marked improvements into results. Young defenders Paddy McNair and Tyler Blackett have shown great promise in the early stages of the campaign but it is to Michael Carrick who the task of reinforcing the Reds’ rearguard is likely to fall. Once viewed as mere stop gap during times of depleted defensive personnel, Carrick now seems more comfortable than ever in the position and performed admirably in the position against City on Sunday alongside rookie McNair. What he lacks in physical prowess he makes up for in experience and reading of the game, a trait that could see him temporarily switched to the position, until January at least.
Losing the derby is always the worst, thankfully I’m fortunate to work in an office in Stretford which is predominantly Red, but that still didn’t numb the gloom that the morning brought. Nevertheless, the hours that followed Sunday’s defeat brought with them a feeling of encouragement that despite our frailties, things were getting better. As I mentioned early, I can’t fathom how some people can’t see this, sometimes I think people are never satisfied. I have some Red mates who are never happy, even in seasons gone by where we’ve won European Cups and league titles they’ve had something to moan about. I mean, seriously, what do they want, blood?
What are your thoughts? Share in the comments section below CLICK HERE.
Like Stretford End Arising on Facebook CLICK HERE.
Register with SEA’s forum CLICK HERE.
I’m going to play devil’s advocate…
The football played has been better this season, but only in patches. Performances have been overrated and I am yet to be convinced by his creative influence on this team. Last season shouldn’t be used as a benchmark. I find comparing the two seasons difficult due to the changes of personnel in the squad. Very few managers would have got a tune out of last season’s squad.
I’ve said previously on SEA that van Gaal is fortunate to be succeeding Moyes and not Fergie. He is also fortunate that other teams have been equally as poor. Everton and Liverpool’s form last season surely contributed to fan frustration and pressure placed on Moyes. Would fans be as patient if Liverpool were playing the same free flowing football and were competing for the title?
Just to be clear, I think we are moving in the right direction, evident by the last two performances, but results are needed. The next three months are huge. Fingers crossed things start to click into place at a quicker rate.
Patience and rational thinking is needed. 90% Of the footballing world dont have those traits and will go along with whatever they hear on skysports. In time United will grow..
On a brighter note, having a line of comparative strangers ahead of him, has allowed and required De Gea to further develop his skills into an absolutely, outstanding keeper. Without his athletic keeping we would certainly not be in the position we are now.
Can it be said however that a more experienced keeper/talker could organise the defence more? Is this why we’re hearing exit rumours?
13 points from 10 games is really depressing, specially with the easy fixture we had. We need to win against palace convincingly. We need to have a winning streak.
To be fair, LVG has brought a brand of football that is exciting and entertaining, but his central defence and the out of form RVP has somehow derailed his philosophy.
It is also fair to say that Luke shaw and Rafael have both impressed whenever they have played.
Marcos Roho has showed glimpses of a good defender but not the finest, yet his injury suggest he will be a huge miss. In my opinion he is a better left back than a central defender. To be fair, again, he can be forgiven for his energy and determination.
Another Central defender worth mentioning is Phil jones. Barr his annoying injuries, he looks a complete stopper who can bring composure in the back 4.
Johnny Evans has not seized his moment even after playing alongside world class centre backs in Vidic and Ferdinand. Instead, he shows signs of a top quality defender, who can use both feet comfortably, but lacks consistency.
As for chris smalling, no comment.
Ion. Wilson deserves a place in the team.
Not so sure the brand of football has been entertaining and exciting. In patches, yes, but we’ve also seen plenty of long punts and aimless crossing. Under Moyes we had more possession, more shots, more goals and more points.
No offence intended, RedKenyan as this is not directed at you, but, I do think people are kidding themselves a little and guilty of seeing what they want to see. Van Gaal is being given the benefit of doubt due to his CV, and probably rightly so.
On Smalling, I think he’s our best natural defender and the defence should be built around him. Yes, he was silly against City, but it was an isolated incident. I think the opinion of Smalling is skewed due to his time at right back. Eight times out of ten he’s been very good at centre back.