5 Things We Learned: Manchester City 1-0 Manchester United


By David Gee (@DavidGee26)

What began with optimism crashed into disappointment as the blue half of Manchester celebrated another derby victory against the Reds.

As is common with derbies, the final score-line perhaps doesn’t reflect the affair and it was far from a routine 1-0 win for the home side. Nevertheless, despite an admirable display of character, with injuries and rash decisions creating havoc within United’s ranks, the result was probably a fair one.

Van Gaal’s side started positively and enjoyed good possession without troubling Joe Hart in City’s goal. The sides seemed evenly matched before the game turning event which saw Chris Smalling inexplicably see red for two yellow card offences, each radiating inexperience and stupidity.

From then on the Reds battled hard with 10 men but the lethal Sergio Aguero proved his quality once more, and despite a spirited final 15 minutes, United were unable to salvage something from the tie.

Defeat against the Blues is always difficult to stomach, but certainly there was pride in the performance despite the result; here are five things we learned from the narrow loss to Pellegrini’s side.

1) David De Gea

One clear positive from Sunday’s game (and from recent weeks in general) has been the form of United’s No.1. Crucial saves from Sergio Aguero kept the Reds in the game right until the final whistle and the Spaniard has really grown into his role.

An outstanding performance against Chelsea was rewarded when United equalised in the dying seconds at Old Trafford and had the Reds been more clinical in front of goal the Spaniard may well have heavily contributed to a more positive result on Sunday.

The nervy performances which characterised De Gea’s early games in a United shirt are increasingly a distant memory. Confident and assured displays have become the norm, something which is even more impressive when considering the lack of consistency in the defence in front of him.

A scrap for a top 4 place is well and truly on and United will need De Gea to maintain his encouraging form.

2) Diamond Di Maria?

Recent weeks have seen Louis van Gaal adopt a 4-3-3 formation in which Angel Di Maria has been playing predominantly wide on the left. However, after an explosive start to his United career the Argentine has carried less influence since the switch.

There is, of course, the argument that his influence is a direct result of the tougher opposition faced but there is no doubt that playing wide starves Di Maria of the ball. Playing on the wing is a difficult and often thankless task; tracking up and down and making lung-busting sprints often without receiving the ball.

When playing in the diamond, Angel was able to drift out to the left when necessary, whilst maintaining a more central presence to enable more influence on the game. It is no coincidence that Di Maria put in his most impressive displays for Real Madrid playing more centrally.

The Argentine is probably the most talented individual at Van Gaal’s disposal and he should be in possession as much as possible. With players now returning from suspensions and injuries it will be interesting to see which formation the Dutchman prefers to persist with.

Whatever Van Gaal chooses, feeding the Argentine the ball as much as possible should be high in his thoughts. Di Maria is a match-winner, but against City he struggled to have as much impact as in previous games. It is now up to United’s manager to get the best out of him.

3) Welcome Back Wayne?

Following Wayne Rooney’s 3-match ban for an ill-advised hack on Stewart Downing, much talk centred around whether Mata was a better option in the side. Rooney inevitably divides opinion and in some ways his performance against City encapsulated both sides of the debate.

Rooney was often wasteful and woefully predictable in possession, the trademark 60-yard switch of play was on display but rarely made it to its target. However, the hunger, the drive and the power at the striker’s disposal nearly resulted in what would have been one of the individual goals of the season.

Moreover, when debating Rooney and Mata’s qualities, far too much emphasis is always placed on the attacking exploits. There is no doubt that in regards to defensive solidity Rooney is perhaps the best No.10 around when deployed there.

Mata failed to take is chance and influence games from his preferred role in Rooney’s absence and the fact remains that the United side always presents a far more compact and solid look with Rooney in it.

Perhaps most pertinently of all, though, is the fact that at this present time the former Everton man is one of worryingly few natural leaders within the squad. For all his indiscretions, United remain a better team with Rooney on the field.

4) Far From Clinical

Despite encouragement stemming from recent performances, the fact remains that United have made their worst start to a season since Ron Atkinson was in charge.

Perhaps the biggest contributor to the lowly points haul has been a lack of clinical finishing in the final third. Van Persie has lacked sharpness in front of goal and had United capitalised on their chances against City (and in other games) the season could have a whole different complexion.

United’s play in the final third has not been incisive or deliberate. Far too many times play has been pensive and chances have been squandered. Against City, Rooney should have shot with his left foot, Di Maria perhaps should have done better with his right-footed effort and Fellaini made a mess of a guilt-edged chance just 6 yards out. Perhaps this is harsh criticism but the biggest games are decided by fine margins.

United’s general play, shape and possession have been improving, but against City once more the inability to take chances cost the Reds. It’s been a similar story all season but for all the talk of the potency of Rooney, Van Persie, Falcao and Di Maria, the goals have yet to start flowing.

5) Perspective

The worst start to a campaign in three decades, just three wins in eleven games, no wins away from home since April and only one win after going behind in 2014; it doesn’t make great reading.

There is no doubt that the last 15 months have been very difficult, but even despite the loss against City there were more encouraging signs. The character and fight in the last 15 minutes against Pellegrini’s men (and against Chelsea for that matter) felt like United.

Yes, the club have made a bad start, but there is a confidence throughout the club that Van Gaal will get it right, and for large parts of the games over the last two weeks United have matched the two sides regarded as the best in the league.

Results will need to improve quickly, but the signs are there that the squad is taking shape and progressing; patience is required.

What are your thoughts? Share in the comments section below CLICK HERE.

Like Stretford End Arising on Facebook CLICK HERE.
Register with SEA’s forum CLICK HERE.

Subscribe via Email

Subscribe to our free email newsletter and never miss a post!

I agree to have my personal information transfered to MailChimp ( more information )

I will never give away, trade or sell your email address. You can unsubscribe at any time.


  1. Rooney’s in one of his out of form spells where everything he does looks awful, Di Maria’s good enough to have the team built around him, Van Persie looks like he’s not happy with not getting the armband & De Gea’s finally starting to look like he could be one of the best…..

    Regardless of whether Utd are in a worse position than last season or not, I feel a lot more confident & happy with where the team is going. Last season was painful to watch & towards the end even got to the point of me not wanting to watch games as I knew it was going to be horrible football.

    If Van Gaal can get some sort of defence in place any time soon – be it January or the end of the season then Utd will be all good.

  2. The problem this season is evidently injuries. These injuries are causing an in balance to the team so we are unable to play our best 11 week in week out which is fair enough. if it was me i would play all our best players in their most effective and best positions and if that means sacrificing certain big names then so be in. Our best players are sacrificed their best position to compensate for somebody with lesser talent to play their better position and for me its not working. LVG doesnt know what to do with the attacking talent we have going forward and how to deploy them.
    As a result the team is unbalanced and players such as Di Maria are played out of position and are sometimes suffering because of it.
    i really have to question what is happening on the training field because not only are players getting injured but players such as Rafael, Smalling, Evans and i would put Jones in that bracket just arent improving and its not good enough. These 4 and making stupid naive and frankly schoolboy amateur mistakes every single game. Our kids such as McNair, Blackett (minus Leicester) and Luke Shaw havent made the catastrophic mistakes these so called experienced first teamers have. i think its time to put faith in some of our prospects like fergie did in 95. I would much rather play somebody with little first team experience but knows the position than somebody with first team experience playing out of position, surely that is what your youth team is for anyway?
    Rafael-Has ability but too rash, wont learn
    Smalling-Woeful, complacent, needs to go
    Jones-needs to play CB, play with his Head
    Evans-positional sense is no existent, crap
    Blind-plays to safe, cant make that great pass
    Valencia-like a robot, cant cross either
    young-just not good enough tbh
    RVP-lacks sharpness,not him self
    mata-needs to do a lot more, like silva
    Januzaj-needs to do more but will improve

Leave A Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.